![](../../wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Untitled-design-86.png)
In this joint interview I. V. Subramaniam or Subbu (Managing Director, CEO & CIO) and Nilesh Shetty (Portfolio Manager) at Quantum Advisors, discuss the bottom-up research and portfolio construction process. The team also shares their experience on how the “Integrity Screen”, adopted in 1996, for evaluating Corporate Governance in India evolved into integrating ESG actively.
Subbu: Over the years, the Indian stock market has had a love/hate relationship with foreign institutional investors. When global risk aversion is low, flows to India significantly increase; we have seen this in 2007, 2010, 2014 and again in 2020 driven by liquidity from global central banks’ easy money policies. In these instances, valuations are no major obstacle as everything is bid up. As soon as risk aversion returns however, investors see the value of their portfolios erode as the fundamentals take precedence and true value is left standing.
India continues to offer great potential with its 1.3 billion-strong consumer market, but government decision making can be erratic, and economic reforms often follow a path of two steps forward and one step back. In the past, investors in India have paid dearly for projecting a goldilocks scenario involving 8%+ GDP growth combined with strong government action. The Indian markets are rife with management teams sporting poor corporate governance track records. So while India is attractive, investors need to guard against these risks and demand an adequate margin of safety. Our long-term track record of delivering 300 basis points of outperformance against the MSCI India Index since inception (31st July 2000) is a testimony to how our investment process can achieve success in the Indian markets while avoiding unnecessary risk.
Nilesh Shetty: Our approach to investing is based on principles of long-term value, detailed bottom-up stock research, and an extremely disciplined process. We are value investors, and we believe we are good at identifying high-quality stocks available at a discount to their intrinsic value with an eye towards that discount getting eliminated over time as the stock is valued appropriately.
Nilesh Shetty: Our goal is to build a diversified portfolio of 25-40 stocks which can generate a reasonable risk-adjusted return. Once the research team determines the buy and sell prices of a stock, the portfolio team – which is also part of the research team – does not second guess it. The portfolio team then uses those pre-determined prices to guide decision making. It is not uncommon for us to add to a stock we already own in between the Buy and Sell prices. We will generally trim the position’s weight when our calculated upside potential falls below that of the India long bond return. Individual stock weights are determined as a function of:
The first three points are afforded the highest importance. For instance, if we are deciding between two stocks with similar upside potential, the one that scores higher on the first three metrics will earn a larger weight. Within this framework, stocks are added at a minimum weight of 2% and a maximum of 6% at cost. On a market value basis, we allow stocks to move up to a maximum of 10% weight and then trim it. Our research is updated at least every 180 days by the covering analyst.
We sell when the stock price reaches our sell limit and there has been no revision in our sell limits, or when we change our view on the management.
Cash is a residual of the portfolio process; we do not take an active call on it. If we do not find new opportunities in which to invest and elect not to add to existing company positions, we are content to hold the cash. Our average cash level since inception is 11.4%. Ideally, we prefer not to have any client restrictions in holding cash, but specific clients do have mandates restricting that weight. In our restriction-free portfolio, the highest cash level we have held was 30% in 2015.
Subbu: There are very few India managers with a history as long as ours. There are even fewer India managers who follow a disciplined value style and can back it up with a track record to match. We believe our focus on a combination of liquidity, corporate governance, valuation, in-house research and a focus on the long term remains unique to the investment landscape in India. We have seen investors suffer heavy losses when they ignore one of the above criteria in India. While it may work in the short term when risk aversion is low, it has tended to inflict significant permanent impairment of capital when risk aversion increases.
In general, our competitive position and strength rests on the following pillars:
In addition to all of the above, our competitive advantage is enhanced by our strong focus on risk assessment before making investments.
Subbu: Given our value investment style, our investment performance tends to mirror how traditional value strategies perform across market scenarios.
We believe that over a complete cycle the style will outperform, but there will be periods of euphoria or irrational exuberance in between in which we are likely to underperform.
Nilesh Shetty: As part of our normal research process, we have always given primary emphasis to corporate governance factors and have excluded those companies that have demonstrated a poor governance track record. From 2015 onwards, based on the increasing importance of non-financial factors (Environment and Social) as well as regulations mandating disclosures on ESG metrics, we developed a proprietary methodology to formally rate companies in our investment universe on these ‘E’, ‘S’, and ‘G’ metrics. We have a six-member team dedicated to ESG research in determining these scores.
Generally, the ESG rating does not serve as the sole determining factor in the decision to include or exclude companies in our portfolio. However, when we observe any portfolio company involved in serious violations of ESG practices and management or the Board demonstrates no intent to improve, the portfolio team will divest the company. For non-portfolio companies, the stock will be placed on “Permanent Watch” and will not be bought – irrespective of market price – until our concerns have been satisfactorily resolved.
Nilesh Shetty: We had several issues with a large Engineering & Construction company which was executing an ecologically-sensitive project without doing any internal studies on the environmental risk involved. (Over and above that, it was accused of facilitating bribes on behalf of one of its clients in seeking permits, as confessed by said client – a US-listed company – in a disclosure to the US Securities and Exchange Commission.)
We wrote the board and sought a meeting with the CEO. In the meeting we were told that with respect to the construction project, the environmental risk assessment remained the client’s responsibility and that it would not conduct said assessment itself. With respect to the bribery allegations, the CEO told us there was no incriminating evidence found in emails or invoices with regards to those projects.
The portfolio team decided to exit the position in April 2019 due to A) a lack of serious effort to uncover any individuals involved in facilitating bribes, and B) the risk that the company may be exposed to large penalties in the future, due to the environmental consequences of ecologically-sensitive projects like the coastal road.
Explore how our two main strategies – Predictable India Equity and India Integrity Equity - with demonstrated success of our tried and tested research and investment processes can ensure your India equity allocation will have higher predictable outcomes and no surprises.
20+ years of India Long-only, Liquid, High-Governance, Margin of safety = Predictability
Integrity screen since 1996, strategy Track record since 2000.
Liquid, proprietary Integrity Scores, Financial Soundness
Integrity Screen since 1996, enhanced criterion since 2015, strategy Track Record since 2019; strategy AuM: $9.7 mn Mandate Capacity: $5 billion
CIN: U65990MH1990PTC055279
SEBI PMS Reg. No.: INP000000187
1st Floor, Apeejay House,
3 Dinshaw Vachha Road, Backbay Reclamation,
Churchgate, Mumbai 400020, India
Tel: +91-22-6144 7900 / 22830322
Fax : 91-22-2285 4318
Email: [email protected]
In case of any grievance/complaint, you may contact Mr. Piyush Thakkar, Chief Executive Officer at [email protected]. Investor can initiate dispute resolution by harnessing online conciliation and/or online arbitration through Online Dispute Resolution (ODR) portal SMARTODR. To know more about grievance redressal mechanism click here.
© 2024 Quantum Advisors India